STAR WARS MARVEL: “THE GARBAGE WILL DO”

It’s about time to talk about the decline of the Marvel Star Wars books. We have had some good series since the old canon reset button was hit a few years back, and there have been some fine issues along the way. Lately though I’ve been increasingly suspicious that the newer books have been taking fans for granted. This site tries to be positive, but also knows that it is unfair to the good material to hand out praise unduly for lesser content.

Firstly though, I am keen to focus on the positive. There has been very good material over the years. The current Darth Vader run is very strong, as were parts of the previous 25 issue series. I love Poe Dameron although the series itself has had its ups and downs. As a series it has that kinetic energy that reflects Star Wars at its Saturday morning matinee best. L’ulo’s funeral was particularly poignant and the humor within the series is really good at times – see Exhibit A Jess Pava’s nickname of ‘The Great Destroyer’.

tumblr_os9otzNFNo1wq7ryqo1_1280

Likewise there have been solid mini-series for Phasma and Maul. These two series struck me as a lot of fun and expanded the character list within the saga, as well as utilizing much loved side characters (Exhibit B Cad Bane and Aurra Sing). I’d go as far as to say that most of the mini and maxi-series have been enjoyable. The early years of the new Marvel era produced a series of strong stories and new characters in the comic format. Likewise I’ve enjoyed both The Force Awakens and Rogue One comic book adaptations, even if the coloring work in the former was a little off. It’s important to realize too that people will have personal preferences, for example Dr Aphra is a real favorite of some fans, but personally I find that book to consist of nothing more than ephemeral nonsense.

Darth-Maul-2_Sing-and-Bane

When the books go bad though, I feel that they go very, very bad. The Yoda arc in the main Star Wars series was miserable and the standard hasn’t picked up since, the Screaming Citadel was a steaming mess, and Mace Windu was atrocious, with interior art as close to objectively awful as a subjective medium can get (Exhibit C).

Mace-Windu-4_Same-Cloth

These books aren’t cheap and it is asking a lot for fans to keep shelling out for them. For this reader, the Marvel Star Wars output is currently striking out at an alarming rate. My wrath though is reserved especially for their series of one-shot comics. Aside from the C-3PO title which I found quite interesting, toying with ideas of droid sentience, there has been a gradual and steep decline. Even that book overplayed its “origins of Threepio’s red arm” shtick.

Cassian and K2-SO was more fluff served up as a cheap trick and a tie in to cash in on Rogue One. The straw that broke this particular Bantha’s back though was the dual impact of the Storms of Crait one shot and the DJ one-shot; part of The Last Jedi tie-ins. The storytelling in both those books was banal in the extreme; the art atrocious. The books represented a new low in the Marvel output. I read a lot of other Marvel and DC books each week (as well as a lot of indie titles), and it is only when you compare the standard that is required from other publications that you can see how lightly Star Wars Marvel gets off. Are the editors giving the artists and writers sufficient time? There is an undoubtedly rushed and slap-dash feel to these books.

crop

I don’t think it’s an exaggeration that most books serving up sub-standard fare would have been discontinued by now. Another confidence trick that I think gets over-deployed is the ruse of variant covers and generally great cover art, but poor internal art. never judge a book by its cover as the old adage goes. Take the DJ book for example – the cover art was awesome – but there is a stark contrast between that and what was found inside (Exhibit D – yes that is DJ). The same with Storms of Crait, which had a sublime cover but which showcased some truly grizzly photo-realistic artwork inside (Exhibit E). I’m deliberately not naming the artists, blame needs to be attributed to those who vetted the work.

Star-Wars-The-Last-Jedi-The-Storms-Of-Crait-2017-001-030

Most of the Star Wars Marvel books are now banking on the brand and the fact that a lot of fans that buy these comics and no others. To those fans I would plea, read some other comics so you can see the chasm between other top titles and the Star Wars fare. There are marvelous, charming, exciting, beautiful books that hit the shelves each week. Hell, look at IDW’s Star Wars line to show how to do a beautifully presented and charming Star Wars comic (see below – I mean look at those last few panels and the witty dialogue).

star-wars-forces-of-destiny-leia-comic-interior-pages-3I can’t say I’m too enthused about the forthcoming attractions from Marvel Star Wars. Do we really need a Thrawn comic with the same plot as the book? What about some new characters or deploying some much loved smaller characters to better effect? Where is the creativity and novelty from the editorial desk? Absent because they know that they don’t need it.

 

I’m opting out of Star Wars comics from now on, having bought every book released to date. There comes a time when good sense and knowing the value of hard earned money makes you realize that staying up to date with canon just isn’t worth it. With two of these flimsy publications costing roughly the same as a good Star Wars paperback, I know where I’ll prioritize my spend. I’m separating myself from the need to acquire all canon output, and I feel fine about it. I’ll stick with Poe and spend the rest of my money elsewhere. Call me when there’s an improvement.

Editor’s Notes: All images subject to copyright and can be removed upon request

8 Comments

  1. Wow, that Storms of Crait artwork is So. Weird.
    I haven’t really kept up with the canon novels, let alone the comics, but it’s a shame they haven’t kept up the quality. You seem to have a pretty objective view on these; I appreciate hearing reasonable critiques as well as praise.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s a balancing act; but I actually feel for the unseasoned artists who are thrust in to do stuff with a tight deadline. The art just looks off to me. Plus the stories are imminently missable at times so they fail to carry it. I think a little more editorial thought and input could help fix this pretty easily.

      Like

  2. I couldn’t agree more. I often marvel (no pun intended) how reading the new Star Wars comics brought me back to comic collecting after seventeen years and now there’s not a single Star Wars title on my pull list. As you said, there are far more creative and entertaining titles to spend my money on.

    What I hadn’t considered before is your point about the slack the Star Wars titles are being given when the content is so often so poor. I can think of a dozen interesting, fun, unique Marvel comics I’ve started over the last few years just to have them cancelled too soon, before they could build the audience they deserve (‘Mockingbird,’ ‘Patsy Walker A.K.A. Hellcat,’ and ‘Luke Cage’ come immediately to mind). There’s SO MUCH to celebrate the comic genre! Star Wars needs to be held to the same level as everything else and/or we need to give titles with smaller audiences the chance to grow too.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. The art is definitely inconsistent and in graphic novels illustrations are extremely important. I just sent you a Twitter message with a picture I found hilarious in The Ashes of Jedha.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. It’s either that, or that they are employing young artists for interior work to save money – if so that’s unfair to the artists. Noticed that a lot of them don’t have an extensive bio on Comixology which is where I buy my books. Another issue may be the writers taking too long and cutting into the artists’ time allocation. Either way it’s got to fall at the feet of editorial.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s